Famed lawyer Ken Starr died unexpectedly Tuesday following issues from surgical procedure after an extended and beforehand undisclosed sickness. He had an extended and storied—and considerably controversial—profession.
Starr, 76, was born in Vernon, Texas, and was a Texan by way of and thru. A graduate of George Washington College and Duke Regulation Faculty (with a grasp’s diploma from Brown College in between), Starr was an early standout. Following a clerkship with a decide on the U.S. fifth Circuit Court docket of Appeals, Starr clerked for Chief Justice Warren Burger on the Supreme Court docket.
Following a short stint in non-public apply, Starr joined President Ronald Reagan’s Justice Division in 1981 as a counselor to Legal professional Normal William French Smith. On the ripe outdated age of 37, Starr was nominated by Reagan to the U.S. Court docket of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit—the second-most highly effective courtroom within the nation—the place he served for six years.
He left the bench—most probably to his remorse—in 1989 to just accept the place of solicitor common below President George H.W. Bush. Between his stint as solicitor common and in non-public apply, Starr argued 36 instances earlier than the Supreme Court docket.
In 1990, following the retirement of Supreme Court docket Justice William Brennan, a liberal icon, Starr was a finalist for the Supreme Court docket seat, as was 5th Circuit Decide Edith Jones, one other stable conservative. The president finally elevated David Souter to the place, who turned a dependable vote with the justices within the liberal bloc of the excessive courtroom to the good disappointment and chagrin of conservatives.
In 1994, in what was maybe the seminal second of his profession, Starr was appointed to succeed Robert Fiske as impartial counsel investigating a failed (and fraudulent) actual property funding within the Whitewater Growth Corp. involving President Invoice Clinton and his spouse, Hillary Clinton, with companion Jim McDougal—who operated a outstanding financial savings and mortgage affiliation in Arkansas—and his spouse, Susan.
Though praised by each side of the political aisle on the time of his appointment for his mind and his integrity, Starr was finally pilloried by Democrats as a partisan hack, together with in a ebook by Democratic strategist-pundit James Carville in his ebook “And the Horse He Rode in On: The Individuals v. Kenneth Starr.”
The scope of Starr’s investigation unexpectedly grew to incorporate different issues, together with the firing of personnel within the White Home Journey Workplace, the suicide (and suspected murder) of White Home aide Vince Foster, and—most famously—an allegation of perjury in reference to a civil sexual harassment lawsuit filed by Paula Jones towards Clinton and earlier than a grand jury that was convened to research the matter, which included mendacity a couple of sexual liaison Clinton had with Monica Lewinsky, a White Home intern.
Regardless of acquiring greater than a dozen convictions associated to that investigation, Starr’s tenure as impartial counsel was overshadowed by the next impeachment—and acquittal—of Clinton for perjury. The investigation so dominated the information that Time journal named Starr and Clinton as its Males of the 12 months in 1998.
In his 2018 memoir “Contempt: A Memoir of the Clinton Investigation,” Starr stated, “I deeply remorse that I took on the Lewinsky part of the investigation.” However, he added, “on the similar time, as I nonetheless see it 20 years later, there was no sensible different to my doing so.”
He additionally famous that “[m]uch of the drama was tragically pointless, for my part, a self-inflicted wound by a proficient however deeply flawed president who confirmed contempt for the regulation, the American folks and the ladies he had used,” including: “But finally, a lot of the nation readily forgave Invoice Clinton and as an alternative blamed the prosecutor: me.”
Starr mirrored on the ability of particular counsels throughout an October 2018 program on the ability and limits of particular counsels that I moderated at The Heritage Basis, which will be seen right here. (The Every day Sign is the information outlet of The Heritage Basis.)
Regardless of the criticism—and Clinton’s acquittal following his impeachment trial—Starr’s successor, Richard Ray, negotiated a decision with Clinton, based mostly largely on the proof that Starr’s workplace uncovered, during which Clinton’s Arkansas regulation license was suspended for 5 years, and he paid a advantageous of $25,000.
Clinton was additionally held in contempt for mendacity throughout his deposition within the Paula Jones case and was fined $90,000 and settled that case by paying $850,000 to Jones.
Following his stint as impartial counsel, Starr served because the dean of Pepperdine Regulation Faculty (the place he employed me as a distinguished practitioner in residence) earlier than being named as president of Baylor School in 2010.
Though a well-liked presence on campus, Starr was demoted and finally resigned from Baylor after an investigation concluded that the college had mishandled allegations of significant sexual misconduct by a number of members of the soccer workforce. Though he denied data of the misconduct or the allegations, he took duty for what occurred, declaring: “The captain goes down with the ship.”
Following his resignation from Baylor in 2016, Starr returned to personal apply, the place he wrote and spoke regularly about spiritual liberty, together with a 2021 ebook, “Non secular Liberty in Disaster: Exercising Your Religion in an Age of Uncertainty.”
He represented a number of outstanding people, together with serving as a member of President Donald Trump’s protection workforce throughout his first impeachment trial, which, just like the Clinton impeachment, additionally resulted in an acquittal.
In an electronic mail after his passing, Starr’s devoted spouse, Alice, referred to as her husband a “sensible, variety, and loving” man who, regardless of what his critics stated, “didn’t have a imply bone in his physique … and he by no means responded in variety to hurtful libel or slander.”
I can attest to all of that, based mostly on my many interactions with Starr through the years.
In a press release following the announcement of his passing, Chief Justice John Roberts stated, “Ken liked our nation and served it with dedication and distinction. He led by instance, within the authorized career, public service, and the neighborhood.”
Might he relaxation in peace.
Have an opinion about this text? To hold forth, please electronic mail [email protected] and we’ll contemplate publishing your edited remarks in our common “We Hear You” function. Bear in mind to incorporate the url or headline of the article plus your title and city and/or state.